Regular Meeting 158, October 30, 2026 (Hybrid)


Evaluation Workshop
This meeting was special in that we focused on learning how to give effective feedback. First, I gave a presentation titled "What and How," based on the "Evaluate to Motivate" project in the "Successful Club" series, a supplementary program to Pathways, the Toastmasters' educational program.
My focus was to discuss some of the most important elements in evaluation speeches. One of them is to determine what purpose the speaker wanted to achieve. We make speeches to achieve a purpose. For example, we speak to encourage the audience to get out of their comfort zone, incorporate a certain way of seeing things, or change how they respond to a challenging situation. We first need to determine the speaker's purpose and then see how effective the materials they used were. This is all about "What" to look at in a speech.
Once we know what to talk about in our evaluation speech, we want to pay attention to "How" we put it into words. Some tips include appreciating the speech first to help the speaker build/keep self-esteem, using "and" when transitioning into suggestions for improvement, and using "I-messages" to make constructive criticism.
Evaluation Practice in Breakouts
After my presentation, we listened to a prepared speech by Toshi, a relatively new member, and everyone, including our guests, put together our evaluation speech before practicing our evaluation speeches in breakout groups. We had five Toastmasters guests and a returning guest new to Toastmasters. It must have been a big challenge for the returning guest, but she delivered a wonderful evaluation speech, partly thanks to the less intimidating breakout environment.
Evaluation speeches are at the core of Toastmasters learning. As we do not have any teachers or instructors and we rely on peer feedback, our evaluation skills play a pivotal role in helping our members improve their public speaking skills. I hope what we learned and practiced at this meeting will help us all in the future.
Hideo Temma
Founding President and Secretary, 2026-2027, Shin-Osaka Leaders Toastmasters Club




Comments